Skip to main content

2024 52 Ancestors: Hard Times - In-between Two Wives

They say it takes a village to rear a child. My 2nd great grandfather, John Alexander Dean, was sure in need of one when Mollie Boyce, his wife (and my 2nd great grandmother), died at the young age of 36 in 1906, leaving behind 5 children to raise.

Mollie, John, Chester, and baby Benjamin Dean, Big Wheeling Creek, West Virginia, circa 1900.

The Deans lived up on a hill from Big Wheeling Creek in West Virginia. John was a blacksmith by trade who also took care of his own farm and raced horses on the side. Mollie was the homekeeper. In addition to raising 4 strapping young boys and 1 beautiful girl, the Deans had also given birth to a set of twins, 1 boy and 1 girl, Arthur and Mary.

Unfortunately, the twins took sick in infancy. The ailment they suffered from differs across sources from thrush to tuberculosis to measles, but whatever afflicted them turned fatal. Sadly, part of the reason may have been lack of medical attention, as they were not the only ones in dire straits.

Mollie, too, was dying. She had breast cancer. Rather than opting for surgery or treatment, she instructed their priest to give them all their last rites as practicing Irish Catholics. Her breast just rotted away, and she and the twins soon all passed away.

John was left a single parent. While the majority of the Dean kids were boys, and most probably old enough to be put to work on the farm, John was still a sudden widower in mourning. The change in family dynamics would have been extremely difficult, on all of them.

To help with the transition, Mollie's younger sister, Nora (Boyce) Murray, moved in as their housekeeper. Nora's husband had kept their family moving about over the years, seemingly chasing after jobs. At the time, he was working as a coal miner in Washington County, Pennsylvania. She had 5 children of her own. Most were lodged at a boarding school in Chartiers, Pennsylvania, and some may have been living with other relatives during this turbulent time. But at least they still had a living mother. Her nephews and niece in West Virginia no longer did, so she helped to fill that gap for them.

John remained a single father for another 6 years before remarrying. In 1912, he took a younger woman, Maggie Seaman, as his new wife. It was her first marriage, but she would need to assume the role of mother to John and Mollie's 5 kids instantaneously. It must have been a challenge she was up for, as the couple then grew their family much larger, adding 6 more children to the brood!

Maggie (Seaman) Dean holding infant, undated.

But the loss of John's first wife was not taken lightly. It left an imprint for many years to come. Even the family's religion changed due to Mollie and the twins' deaths. The Dean family went from being Catholic to Presbyterian, allegedly tied to two main reasons; one, that the priest seemingly did nothing to try and save the babies' lives but would only absolve them of their earthly sins, and two, that when Mollie's brother-in-law later died, the Catholic church refused to hold mass for him until Mollie's sister paid them a large sum of money because he was not a regular church-goer.

According to John and Mollie's granddaughter, Sheila (Dean) Pendleton, in a letter written on 10 April 2019, John's children, who had all been raised in the Catholic faith, denounced Catholicism from that moment on. The family burial patterns also changed from most taking place in Mt. Calvary Catholic Cemetery in Wheeling to later ones in Peninsula, Stone Church, or Sherrard cemeteries. Even John was not buried with his 1st wife Mollie at Mt. Calvary. His children opted for him to be at Peninsula instead.

The loss of Mollie and the twins really placed the Dean family through some hard times. The 6 years after his wife's death in which John remained single likely speaks to the amount of sorrow and grief that hit him and the children. It would have been a difficult period for all of them, as well as Mollie's sister Nora who stepped in to help, all of her children who had to sacrifice that time with their own mother, and of course Maggie Seaman who then took on the burden of an entire household when she became John's 2nd wife.

Letter by Sheila (Dean) Pendleton to Kira D. Foltz, 20 Jan 2021.

Dean family reunion, Wheeling Park, West Virginia, 14 Aug 1949.

The Dean family's fortunes, while not completely turning around after Mollie's passing, at least evened out afterwards. And John's 2 families continued on as 1 throughout the years, all under the Dean banner. A century later, all of his living descendants (from both Mollie and Maggie's lines) were tracked down and informed we still all owned the mineral rights to the land that sat on Big Wheeling Creek.





Comments

Popular posts from this blog

2025 52 Ancestors: At the Library - First Outing to FamilySearch in Salt Lake City

Every genealogist should eventually make the trek out to SLC to visit the FamilySearch Library (formerly known as the Family History Library). It is open access and free to the public, like a city library, except it is wholly focused on genealogy research materials and managed by the company FamilySearch (founded by The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints). Kira D. Foltz, photo of entrance to FamilySearch Library, Salt Lake City, UT, Mar 2025. One of the genealogy societies I belong to, Ventura County Genealogical Society ( VCGS ), makes an annual pilgrimage to the library on what they have termed the Salt Lake City Safari. I learned about their trip a couple years ago and felt I'd need to tag along when the schedule made sense for me. 2025 was the year! James McAleney, photo of VCGS Safari group at FamilySearch Library, Salt Lake City, UT, Mar 2025. Used with permission. A group of about 35 of us joined together in Utah for a week in March filled with family history resea...

RootsTech Revelations!

Unfortunately I still have not yet had the chance to attend a RootsTech genealogy conference in person, however, 2025 marks the fourth year in a row I've watched virtually since their quick and nimble transition during the COVID-19 pandemic in 2021. I'm quite thankful for the plethora of videos and keynote presentations FamilySearch has offered online since that point in history, and for FREE, nonetheless! In the handful of presentations I've managed to view or listen to so far this year, there was one put on by Claire Bradley , a Dublin-based genetic genealogist, that helped me strike gold in my research! Her talk was called Irish Genealogy Resources at the Virtual Treasury . It explored the holdings of the Virtual Record Treasury of Ireland which has had the goal of recreating an online database of documents lost during the Four Courts Fire of 1922 at the Public Record Office of Ireland.  Obviously, due to the devastating destruction at that archive, many original recor...

2025 52 Ancestors: Favorite Name - Jesse L. Pitcock

Jesse Pitcock's name might appear fairly average upon first examination, but there's something fun hidden in his middle name. He was my 1st cousin 4x removed on one of my mother's lines. And before a day ago, I didn't even know he existed, let alone would have picked him for this blog's subject line. But due to coincidental timing this week, I happened to discover him and have the perfect opportunity to shine a spotlight on him and his family. Jesse was born in 1890 in Greene County, Pennsylvania to parents John and Sidney Pitcock. John was my 3rd great granduncle. I believe Jesse was their youngest child out of 9 kids! He went on to marry a woman named Lucy John and they had 5 daughters together. Now, I don't have any strong evidence to back up this suspicion, but I believe Jesse's parents had a wonderful sense of humor. Jesse's name only sprung out at me while leafing through my Ancestry.com tree's image hints. His obituary had been uploaded by ano...