Skip to main content

Fatal Naming Pattern

 MARCH 21, 2021

Week 12: Loss

There’s a disturbing trend that I noticed while studying my family tree over the years that relates to the use of a specific name. It’s a name that I’m rather fond of – Emmet. But it appears to be tied to unfortunate tragedy.

Unknown photographer, sepia-toned image of infant Nathan Emmet Dixon deceased in casket, 1902, West Virginia, held in private collection of descendant Kira D. Foltz. Photo has some rips and damage to sides and corners, “AT REST” is etched into the t…

Unknown photographer, sepia-toned image of infant Nathan Emmet Dixon deceased in casket, 1902, West Virginia, held in private collection of descendant Kira D. Foltz. Photo has some rips and damage to sides and corners, “AT REST” is etched into the top of the photograph with a backward “S” and “1902” is etched onto the lower half of the photograph.

NATHAN EMMET DIXON

My great granduncle was born to Elizabeth Beatrice Rockwell and Nathan Dixon on February 4th, 1902 and died just 7 months later of blood poisoning. His casket photo is seemingly the only photo surviving of him as an infant.


Unknown photographer, picture of Lloyd E. Dean’s totaled automobile, 1955, Wheeling, West Virginia, held in private collection of Kira D. Foltz.

Unknown photographer, picture of Lloyd E. Dean’s totaled automobile, 1955, Wheeling, West Virginia, held in private collection of Kira D. Foltz.

LLOYD EMMET DEAN

My granduncle made it just barely to adulthood. He was born 28 November 1936 in Sherrard, West Virginia to Beatrice Bethel Dixon and Chester Joseph Dean. Almost as if he knew his life was to be a short one on Earth, he got married young at the age of 17 to Jewell Ann Straub on 5 June 1954. And the couple gave birth to a boy, Michael Andrew Dean, just five short months later!

Lloyd went from becoming an adult to becoming a husband to becoming a father all within a span of less than a year. And sadly, that was all that he was to experience of his adult life, as he suddenly passed away when his car was T-boned on 17 July 1955 in Wheeling, West Virginia right in front of the hospital, in fact. He was buried at Halcyon Hills Cemetery. His wife and son were also injured in the crash, but survived. A newspaper account describes the event below.

Wheeling Intelligencer, “Local Man, 19, Dies, 5 Injured in Crash,” 18 July 1955, Wheeling, West Virginia, p. 1; online database, Ohio County Public Library (https://www.ohiocountylibrary.org : accessed 21 Mar 2021) > OCPL Digital Newspaper Archiv…

Wheeling Intelligencer, “Local Man, 19, Dies, 5 Injured in Crash,” 18 July 1955, Wheeling, West Virginia, p. 1; online database, Ohio County Public Library (https://www.ohiocountylibrary.org : accessed 21 Mar 2021) > OCPL Digital Newspaper Archives, search for fatal car in July 1955.

Unknown photographer, picture of Lloyd E. Dean’s totaled automobile, 1955, Wheeling, West Virginia, held in private collection of Kira D. Foltz.

Unknown photographer, picture of Lloyd E. Dean’s totaled automobile, 1955, Wheeling, West Virginia, held in private collection of Kira D. Foltz.

Unknown photographer, picture of Lloyd E. Dean’s totaled automobile, 1955, Wheeling, West Virginia, held in private collection of Kira D. Foltz.

Unknown photographer, picture of Lloyd E. Dean’s totaled automobile, 1955, Wheeling, West Virginia, held in private collection of Kira D. Foltz.


EMMETT LEE BALES

Daisy Pearl Ruse and David Russell Bales’ boy, my 3rd cousin once removed, had a similarly shortened life, it would seem. He was born in West Virginia in 1937 and according to my records died at the age of 23 in 1960. It’s possible I could have this one incorrect, as there appear to be a few Emmett Lee Bales around this time period that hail from Braxton County. Some day I will need to delve into his life more to be sure.

Sutton High School, “U.S., School Yearbooks, 1880-2012,” 1954, Sutton, West Virginia; U.S., School Yearbooks, 1900-1999, online database with images, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com : accessed 21 Mar 2021) > West Virginia > Sutton > Sutt…

Sutton High School, “U.S., School Yearbooks, 1880-2012,” 1954, Sutton, West Virginia; U.S., School Yearbooks, 1900-1999, online database with images, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com : accessed 21 Mar 2021) > West Virginia > Sutton > Sutton High School > 1954 > “Sophomores.” Emmett Bales is listed 2nd in the members of the class, but unknown where he appears in photograph of class.


EMMETT CARL AUFRANC

Finally, this Emmett, also my 3rd cousin once removed, seems to be the luckiest of the bunch. He lived to be 44 years of age, born in 1915 in Missouri and died in 1959. That’s still quite a short life span, though!

David Henry Hickman High School, “U.S., School Yearbooks, 1880-2012,” 1933, Columbia, Missouri; U.S., School Yearbooks, 1900-1999, online database with images, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com : accessed 21 Mar 2021) > Missouri > Columbia &g…

David Henry Hickman High School, “U.S., School Yearbooks, 1880-2012,” 1933, Columbia, Missouri; U.S., School Yearbooks, 1900-1999, online database with images, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com : accessed 21 Mar 2021) > Missouri > Columbia > David Henry Hickman High School > 1933 > “SENIORS.” Emmett Aufranc is pictured as the 4th image in the left-hand column.


So there ya have it!

All 4 men who carried the Emmet or Emmett name in the family perished way too soon. And while it may lean to being rather superstitious, if I were to be asked how to prevent a tragic loss of a loved one occurring in the future, my first response would be to not name that child Emmet!

Just in case…

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

2025 52 Ancestors: At the Library - First Outing to FamilySearch in Salt Lake City

Every genealogist should eventually make the trek out to SLC to visit the FamilySearch Library (formerly known as the Family History Library). It is open access and free to the public, like a city library, except it is wholly focused on genealogy research materials and managed by the company FamilySearch (founded by The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints). Kira D. Foltz, photo of entrance to FamilySearch Library, Salt Lake City, UT, Mar 2025. One of the genealogy societies I belong to, Ventura County Genealogical Society ( VCGS ), makes an annual pilgrimage to the library on what they have termed the Salt Lake City Safari. I learned about their trip a couple years ago and felt I'd need to tag along when the schedule made sense for me. 2025 was the year! James McAleney, photo of VCGS Safari group at FamilySearch Library, Salt Lake City, UT, Mar 2025. Used with permission. A group of about 35 of us joined together in Utah for a week in March filled with family history resea...

2025 52 Ancestors: Favorite Name - Jesse L. Pitcock

Jesse Pitcock's name might appear fairly average upon first examination, but there's something fun hidden in his middle name. He was my 1st cousin 4x removed on one of my mother's lines. And before a day ago, I didn't even know he existed, let alone would have picked him for this blog's subject line. But due to coincidental timing this week, I happened to discover him and have the perfect opportunity to shine a spotlight on him and his family. Jesse was born in 1890 in Greene County, Pennsylvania to parents John and Sidney Pitcock. John was my 3rd great granduncle. I believe Jesse was their youngest child out of 9 kids! He went on to marry a woman named Lucy John and they had 5 daughters together. Now, I don't have any strong evidence to back up this suspicion, but I believe Jesse's parents had a wonderful sense of humor. Jesse's name only sprung out at me while leafing through my Ancestry.com tree's image hints. His obituary had been uploaded by ano...

2025 52 Ancestors: Institutions - Uncovering the Story of Cousin Eddie Dean

There's about a million "Eddies" in my family tree, which automatically puts me off in terms of researching any of them, because on the surface, they already don't seem very unique or interesting. However, at this point in my genealogy journey, I should definitely know better. Everyone has a fascinating story to tell, even if their name isn't as glamorous or one-of-a-kind. Eddie Dean is one of those cousins who I didn't think twice about when I initially saw his leaf dangling on my maternal branch. But in 2009, I travelled to Oklahoma for a family gathering and learned little nuggets of info here and there on my mom's Dean side from three of my great aunts, Frances, Sheila, and Thelma. I was curious about their brother, Raymond, who had passed away long before I was even born. From what I gathered, Raymond had had a wife and two sons. And yet, I found it odd that I did not know this great aunt of mine or her kids (who would be around my mom's generatio...